Cloud Nine is a 1979 play by Caryl Churchill which explores the parallel between colonial and sexual oppression. She does this by purposefully taking gender and racial stereotypes and overturning them, using cross-gender and even cross-racial casting (Seal 2012). At the time, two large movements in Britain were gaining momentum; the gay rights movement and the feminist movement, both of which would have impacted Churchill’s writing. Churchill has been praised for Cloud Nine and her ability to capture the attitudes of the time, using these social movements as well as the confusion of a fast changing society (Ashton and Diamond 2009). Through a close reading of most of the characters, this essay aims to show the effects of the various forms of oppression they endure.
Clive is the resident patriarch, stating in his opening lines, “I am father to the natives here, and father to my family so dear.” (p. 1) and is the middle man between the parallel of colonial and sexual oppression. He begins at the top of the racial and family hierarchy, but throughout act one, his status begins to diminish. He does not seem to recognise his own hypocrisy; he asks his wife to be faithful to him and yet he himself aggressively makes sexual advances after another woman. Clive is constantly instructing the other characters throughout act one to either enter or exit, forcing the other characters to be in a continual state of adapting to new circumstances. His unwavering belief in these patriarchal structures means that these beliefs are forced upon the women and children in his home. Churchill includes notes on how to cast specific characters in the copies of Cloud Nine, which reflects heavily on the themes she is trying to portray. The idea of a quest for an identity is brought up when taken into account the gender-bending cross-casting of some of the characters (Stanton and Banham 1996). Betty, Clives wife, is cast as a man, and in her introduction to the audience says, “I am a man’s creation you see, What men want, I want to be.” (p. 1) enforcing the idea that femininity is a male creation. Diamond (2003, p. 87) argues, “Betty, the male centered, male subservient angel of the house, is literally man made.” Clives daughter, Victoria, isn’t even cast as a person in act one and is instead substituted by a doll, adhering to the classic Victorian patriarchal beliefs of young children, especially girls, to be seen and not heard. This is taken to the absolute extreme by casting her as an inanimate object. Clives son, Edward, is cast as a woman, highlighting Clives futile attempts to impose traditional masculinity upon his son, who is shown to have a penchant for playing with his sisters dolls and his inability to throw straight.
The sexuality of individuals, like the bisexual Harry Bagley and the lesbian Ellen, are denied and disputed throughout act one. Characters establish themselves in relation to Clive. Harry hides his homosexuality from him out of fear, as does Edward and Betty tries to resist her feelings for Harry out of loyalty. Ellen tries to clearly state her feelings, much to Betty’s obliviousness (p. 27):
Ellen I don’t hate you Betty, I love you.
Betty Harry says we shouldn’t go away. But he says he worships me.
Ellen I worship you Betty.
Betty Oh Ellen, you are my only friend.
This is one of the only instances in act one where homosexuality is actively seen on stage. The other relationships are obscured by the casting choices: Harry and Edward’s relationship is changed because Edward is played by a woman, so is visually a heterosexual relationship; Harry and Betty’s relationship, despite Betty being played by a man, is typically heteronormative since Betty is meant to be a woman; this use of cross-gender casting thereby embodying homoerotic desires as conventional heterosexual relationships (Harding 1998). The other display of homosexuality is between Harry and Clive, when Harry makes a pass at him having misunderstood the situation. Having been outed, act one ends with two of the more openly homosexual characters being married together, at the hand of Clive, who strives to maintain the crumbling world he wishes to see by oppressing everything that falls outwith the norm. Marriage is usually used within dramatic comedies to mark the restoration of traditional family values (Ashton in Kohlke and Gutleben 2011), something which Clive would have believed in deeply. Churchill uses the notion of cross-dressing to express the idea of disguise within the characters as a way of life (McIntyre and Buchbinder 1987).
Much like the gender and sexual identity being dictated and oppressed, so is the racial identity of the African characters (McCullough 1996). Joshua is a black servant and yet the actor who is cast to play him must be white, according to Churchills specific casting notes for the play. In his introduction, Joshua says, “My skin is black but oh my soul is white. I hate my tribe. My master is my light. I only live for him As you can see, What white men want is what I want to be.” (p. 2), sharing a similarity for Betty being cast as a man, Joshua is cast as a white actor because that is what Clive wants him to be. His need to separate himself is also heavily reinforced in a later exchange between Joshua and Mrs Saunders, following the flogging of people from a nearby tribe (p. 32):
Mrs Saunders You don’t mind beating your own people?
Joshua Not my people, madam.
Mrs Saunders A different tribe?
Joshua Bad people.
This kind of determined attitude to remain separate from his roots shows how his identity has been shaped by internalising Clives racism and how he has been oppressed (Kritzer 1991); much like Harry and Ellen’s sexualities, who both express a hatred for their desires in act one. However, Joshua’s attitude begins to change after the revelation that his parents have been killed by British soldiers. Joshua attempts to remain distanced from the incident, refusing to take the day off or to even attend his parents funeral, act one ends with him aiming a gun at Clive; an event that Edward does not try and prevent, despite having seen Joshua in plenty of time to warn his father. This act of betrayal highlights the resentment Edward harbours for his father.
Act two is set technically hundreds of years later, however the characters themselves have only aged by twenty-five years. By doing this, Churchill introduces the idea that the past and present will always be linked (Jenkyns 2006). In act two, colonisation aspect has moved from the British occupation of Africa to the post-colonial presence in Northern Ireland (Patterson 2007). As it is post-colonial, the characters exist in a post-Clive environment; now free from the patriarchal structures imposed upon them, the genders of the actors cast for the characters change, highlighting this freedom and its effects. Both Edward and Betty are performed by their correct respective genders as they both begin to grow into their real selves and discover their sexualities (Patterson 2003), showing a greater sexual freedom. The only example of a character being cross-gender cast is a little girl called Cathy, Lin’s daughter, who is played by a man. This is used in response to Edwards upbringing. Instead of having traditional values imposed on her, Lin encourages Cathy to play with guns and other “masculine” toys, and doesn’t try to dress her in “feminine” clothing. However, Cathy rebels against this liberated upbringing, insisting that her mother buy her dresses for school. This clearly depicts the issues that arise when thinking about what can be considered as correct behaviour for a girl - or, as in act one, the correct behaviours for a boy.
As the second act is set within “present day” London in the 1970’s, this coincides with the movement of second wave feminism, as well as the gay rights movement. Churchill writes in an introduction to Cloud Nine that more energy in the act stems from the women and homosexuals. She also mentions that the male characters find it difficult to relinquish control - this is personified by Victoria’s husband, Martin. Martin is painted as someone who wants to catch up with the change that is happening around him and is failing to do so. He is confused as he doesn’t know how to deal with his previous need to dominate, as that is something he cannot do any more as the roles of women were rapidly changing (Jenkyns 2006) and the sexual politics were evolving. This is highlighted when, after participating in an orgy with Victoria, Lin and Edward, Martin says, “I was all for the sixties when liberation just meant fucking.” (p. 75). The play ends with a liberated modern time Betty faces her oppressed Victorian self after being scolded by a disappointed Clive who haunts her, where the two embrace as present day Betty comes to terms with herself (Mihaylova 2008).
Churchill used cross-gender and cross-racial casting to explore the similarities between colonial and sexual oppression. She subverted the stereotypes surrounding women, homosexuality and race, which was viewed as controversial, however, this was common for feminist theatre at the time (Coyle et al. 2002). Churchill expresses the ways in which imposing certain ideals on children can be harmful, shown through Edward and Cathy, and subsequently how the notion of embracing gender and sexuality are crushed by the patriarchy.
References
ASHTON, E., DIAMOND, E., 2009. The Cambridge Companion to Caryl Churchill. New York: Cambridge University Press.
COYLE, M., GARSIDE, P., KELSALL, M., PECK, J., 2002. Encyclopaedia of Literature and Criticism. London: Routledge
CHURCHILL, C., 1978. Cloud Nine. London: Pluto Press Ltd. and Joint Stock Theatre Group
DIAMOND, E., 2003. Unmaking Mimesis: Essays on Feminism and Theatre. London: Routledge.
HARDING, J., 1998. Cloud Cover: (Re) Dressing Desire and Comfortable Subversions in Caryl Churchill's Cloud Nine. PMLA. Vol. 133, no. 2. pp. 15
JENKYNS, M., 2006. The Play’s the Thing: Exploring Text in Drama and Therapy. London: Routledge
KOLKE M., GUTLEBEN, C., 2011. Neo-Victorian Families: Gender, Sexual and Cultural Politics. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
KRITZER, A., 1991. The Plays of Caryl Churchill. London: The MacMillan Press
MACINTYRE, M. and BUCHBINDER, D. 1987. Having It Both Ways: Cross-Dressing in Orton's What the Butler Saw and Churchill's Cloud Nine. Journal of Dramatic Theory and Criticism, Vol.2 (no.1), pp. 34.
MCCULLOUGH, C., 1996. Theatre and Europe, 1957-95. Exeter: Intellect Books
MIHAYLOVA, S., 2008. From Gestus to the Abject: Feminist Strategies in Contemporary British and American Radical Theatre. Doctor of Philosophy. Northwestern University.
PATTERSON, M., 2003. Strategies of Political Theatre: Post-War British Playwrights. New York: Cambridge University Press
PATTERSON, M., 2007. The Oxford Guide to Plays. New York: Oxford University Press
SEAL, K., 2012. Gender Politics in Caryl Churchill’s Cloud Nine. [online] India. pp. 203 [viewed 29 November 2014]. Available from: https://www.thecho.in/files/Gender-Politics-In-Caryl-Churchil-s-Cloud-Nine.pdf
STANTON, S., BANHAM, M., 1996. The Cambridge Paperback Guide to Theatre. New York: Cambridge University Press.